A contrast between the puritan and indian cultures in mary rowlandson writings

The Matron and the Minister: Canavan In reading the incredibly moving text of The Sovereignty and Goodness of God, a detailed narrative of Mary Rowlandson's eleven week captivity among Narragansett Indians, one cannot help but become aware of the presence of two distinct and alternating narrative voices throughout the body of the text. In fact, numerous scholars have taken pause to make note of this undeniable shift in voice within their critical reflections of Rowlandson's narrative.

A contrast between the puritan and indian cultures in mary rowlandson writings

Although most of us are not incredibly familiar with the Indian captivity genre, it's not hard to see that Mary Rowlandson is not treated with the same brutality that her fellow prisoners receive. The first Indians who speak with her assure her that she won't be hurt if she comes with them without trouble; this is quite different from Rowlandson's description of people being knocked on the head and carried away.

She faces the cruelty of her mistress, but it is tempered by the kindness of her master who promises to sell her back to her husband, by the other squaws who feed her, and by the various Indians who pay her with food and other tradable goods for her sewing.

She is not tortured. She is not raped. Ask yourself, is her treatment what we'd expect from savages?

Links of Interest

Rowlandson's Puritanism Mary Rowlandson's captivity narrative provides an excellent example of many aspects of Puritan theology. When her wound is healed after an oak leaf poultice is applied, she recognizes her fortune as "the blessing of God. According to Rowlandson once she returns to her family, God demonstrates his providence by preserving the Indians in the face of adversity for the sole purpose of acting as a means of punishment for a lack of spirituality in His chosen people.

God strengthened them to be a scourge to His people" because ". Rowlandson asserts that God's power to save remains as strong and "as great now. She remembers a time when she harbored vain thoughts and thanks God for the trials that have brought her to the realization that "they are the vanity of vanities, and vexation of spirit, that they are but a shadow, a blast, a bubble, and things of no continuance.

A contrast between the puritan and indian cultures in mary rowlandson writings

That we must rely on God Himself, and our whole dependence must be upon Him. Throughout her captivity, Rowlandson turns to the Bible for comfort and support. Rowlandson credits God with showing her the specific Bible verses that she needs over and over: Rowlandson knows the Bible.

She obviously believes in God and His saving power. She also believes that her race is superior to the native race. These two episodes show another side of Rowlandson, but it's not a side that is unexplainable or not compatible with Mary, the Christian.

She is a product of her society and thus even more human than the "perfect Christian.The notion that Winthrop sought to create a strictly Puritan society whose basis rested upon Puritan idealism is reinforced when he states that people are different in three ways which are ordained by God.

yunusemremert.comity among people allows for a variety of ways in which God may be honored. A Clash of Cultures Mary Rowlandson's “The Account of Mary Rowlandson and Other Indian Captivity Narratives” shows two different sides of the Indian people.

This narrative describes Rowlandson's experience as a captive of an Indian tribe that raided the town of Lancaster in Comparing Author's Views! Ann Branstreet and Mary Rowlandson vs. William Bradford and John Winthrop Each of these author draw upon their deep-rooted Puritan faith, to better express their intentions of write.

All wrote in a tone that acknowledged God's hand in their life. A bestselling tale of passion and belief, magic and adventure from the author of The Secret Chord and of March, winner of the Pulitzer Prize. Bethia Mayfield is a restless and curious young woman growing up in Martha's vineyard in the s amid a small band of pioneering English Puritans.

A uniquely American literary genre, the captivity narrative recounts the experience of a white European or, later, an American, during his or (more usually) her captivity and eventual release from hostile enemy captors (generally Native Americans). Although Mary Rowlandson cannot be credited with single handedly creating the American genre known as the "Indian captivity narrative" it is safe to say that her account of her eleven week captivity was one of the earliest and most popular narratives of its type.

A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson - Wikipedia